Cart Summary

Oh no, your cart is empty.

Add something awesome to it!

Serial Killer Fan Pins and Buttons

Search Results
Get 25% OFF when you buy 4+ pins!
*Cannot be combined with additional sales/discounts.

Jeff Boyardee Pin

by creepyjason
$2.75 $2.00

Serial killer inspiration Pin

by Venom Reign
$2.75 $2.00

The Bay Harbor Butcher (worn look) Pin

by MoviTees
$2.75 $2.00

Pogo the Clown Pin

by Crowjan Designs
$2.75 $2.00

Serial Killers *EXTENDED* Pin

by LVBart
$2.75 $2.00

Aileen Wuornoes "Halo" Pin

by BustedBones
$2.75 $2.00

Cooking With Kids Pin

by dflynndesigns
$2.75 $2.00

Serial Hair Pin

by LVBart
$2.75 $2.00

The Night Stalker Richard Ramirez Pin

by crimetime
$2.75 $2.00

Manson Pin

by creepyjason
$2.75 $2.00

T-Shirts & More_Serial Killer @ Heart Pin

by texaspoetrope
$2.75 $2.00

You ispire my inner serial killer Pin

by valentinahramov
$2.75 $2.00

I Don't like Mondays Brenda Spencer Pin

by The Horror Basement & Beyond
$2.75 $2.00

The Night Stalker Richard Ramirez Pin

by crimetime
$2.75 $2.00

Albert Fish's Canned Goods Pin

by dflynndesigns
$2.75 $2.00

Serial killer pop art trio Pin

by crimetime
$2.75 $2.00

Smells like Albert Fish Pin

by Zerowear
$2.75 $2.00

Alibi Establish Bloody Hands Funny Creepy Pin

by Mellowdellow
$2.75 $2.00

John Wayne Gacy Pogo The Clown Pin

by BustedBones
$2.75 $2.00

Discuss Serial Killers Pin

by TheBestHumorApparel
$2.75 $2.00

You ispire my inner serial killer Pin

by valentinahramov
$2.75 $2.00

Killer Clown Pin

by weckywerks
$2.75 $2.00

Fritz Honka Serial Killer Shirt Pin

by BustedBones
$2.75 $2.00

Not a Serial Killer Pin

by dflynndesigns
$2.75 $2.00

Serial Killer Start Kit Pin

by The Awesome Corner Shop
$2.75 $2.00

Cereal Killer Pin

by BasicBeach
$2.75 $2.00

Zodiac killer Pin

by valentinahramov
$2.75 $2.00

Best Friend Pin

by MasticisHumanis
$2.75 $2.00

Pin FAQ

Where can I find other serial killer designs?
In addition to serial killer designs, you can explore the marketplace for true crime, true crime gift, and true crime junkie designs sold by independent artists.
What material is this item made of?

Classic pin-back button covered with scratch and UV-resistant mylar. Printed in the U.S.A.

What USA ship methods are available?

Standard (6-8 Business Days)

FedEx Air (4-6 Business Days)

Estimates include printing and processing time. More Shipping Info »

What is the Return/Exchange policy?

We want you to love your order! If for any reason you don't, let us know and we’ll make things right. Learn More »